Friday, February 22, 2019

Fiqh of Haydh notes

(Notes from Rabata.org's workshop on Fiqh of Haydh, featuring female scholars from each madh'hab.)

Spiritual Connectivity During Menstruation (Shehnaz Karim)

Allah created everything with meaning - including our menstrual cycles and other uniquely female bodily functions.

Being on our periods does not mean that we are disconnected from Allah or on a “vacation” from worshiping Allah.

There are many ways to worship during menses.

  • Strive to be at peace with the idea of menstruation and the rulings about with regards to ritual acts of worship
  • Use this time to contemplate our relationship with Allah, reflect on what it means to be connected to Allah outside of specific ritual actions.
  • An hour of tafakkur is better than 70 years of worship
  • Tafakkur has its own adab
  • Reflect on Allah’s blessings upon us; think about your own personal shortcomings; thank Allah for covering our faults and weaknesses - don’t be depressed by your weakness, but thank Allah for His Mercy on us; realize that nothing and no one can harm or benefit us except Allah.
  • Use this tafakkur as a means of rejuvenating you spiritually throughout the day. Build and develop an awareness of Allah in your everyday life.
  • Connect with Allah’s Name al-Khaaliq: the Creator. He created us with our menstrual cycles for a reason: it is unique to women, it is a part of how the human race procreates. Allah’s name arRahman: comes from ‘rahm,’ the womb - which is connected to our menstrual cycles. Allah has unconditional love and nurtures us accordingly; we, as women, have the unique potential to also have unconditional love and nurturing.
  • Allah’s Mercy is also manifested in the rulings surrounding menses: we do not pray or fast, so that we may rest, eat and drink - we are to nurture our bodies.

Shafi’i Fiqh of Menses (Anse Marah Dahman)

Definition of Haydh:
The flow of blood from the vagina, excluding post-partum bleeding and vaginal bleeding due to illness or other medical factors.

Istihaadha: any vaginal bleeding that is not post-partum bleeding or menstrual bleeding. (E.g. bleeding post-IUD-insertion; irregular bleeding due to PCOS.)

Colour: Literally any colour whatsoever. Pink, red, orange, black, brown.

Minimum age: 9 lunar years; no maximum age.

Shortest menstrual cycle: One day and one night (24 hours).

Maximum length of cycle: 15 days and nights.

Minimum period of taharah: 15 days and nights

Prohibitions During Haydh
  • Obligatory ghusl (??)
  • Salah
  • Tawaf
  • Fasting
  • Touching mus’haf or holding it
  • Staying in the masjid
  • Intercourse
  • Divorce


Is my period over?
  • Any colour before white discharge at end of period still counts as menstrual blood
  • Even if white but has pink bits in it - still your period
  • Go by your *usual* cycle - if you are someone who has regular patterns/ times/ cycle
  • If not sure, self-swab. (Q-tips, tampon, cotton strip/rag.)
  • White or clear discharge indicates end of period
  • Any yellow/ beige etc after white discharge is not considered period
  • If you tend to have very little discharge in general and are dry for a day, with no bleeding - self swab to check for any potential blood.
  • Wait for a MAXIMUM of one day to determine no more blood.
  • Some say wait for a maximum of three fardh prayers; if nothing, then do your ghusl and pray.

Istihaadha:

  • Any non-menstrual, non-post-partum bleeding
  • Various reasons for it: medical condition, or something like IUD insertion
  • Can have various colours/ flows. Can be similar to menstrual blood, or could be totally different.
  • Even if it seems like menstrual blood, does not count as menses unless it is taking place within what is normally considered your cycle. (E.g. if your maximum menstrual cycle is 7 days, count it as 7 days - anything after, consider as istihaadhah.)
  • You are still considered taahir. You pray, fast, have intercourse, etc.
  • Any bleeding that exceeds 15 days is automatically istihaadha
  • If you did not pray or fast during days of istihaadha, you MUST make up those prayers and fasting
  • If your cycle changes due to a big difference in your life - e.g. IUD, illness - and you aren’t yet sure of new menstrual pattern, then you can take one month as an “experimental” one - keep track of the bleeding and any changes that take place, try to match what is normally part of your cycle (in terms of patterns, consistency, etc). You are not sinful for not praying/fasting days that turn out to be istihaadha but you were originally unsure due to major changes. Just ensure that you make up those prayers and fasts!
  • If you bleed again BEFORE 15 days of tahaarah have been completed, it is still considered istihaadha. E.g. spotting during ovulation
  • If you bleed again AFTER 15 days of tahaarah, but considered ‘early’ for your period - consider it your period.
  • Use a calendar! There are also lots of menstrual apps that allow you to add notes so that you can keep track of details. Or, keep a menstrual journal.
  • Do a fresh wudhu for every fardh salah. Then you can pray as much as you want with that wudhu, within that time period (e.g. sunan, qiyaam), until you nullify your wudhu through ‘normal’ means.


Miscellaneous:

  • If your period ends while you are somewhere that you have no access to showers for ghusl, you can do tayammum instead of ghusl, and then do wudhu if you have access to a sink - so that you can catch a prayer on time. (If you are not home, but at a mall, it is time for salah, your period definitely ended - do tayammum, then do wudhu in the bathroom sink, and pray.)


Hanafi Fiqh (Farzana Chowdhury)

Haydh: Blood which flows from the womb of a mature female, that is not the result of illness, pregnancy, and not post-menopausal.

Earliest age: 9

Minimum duration: 3 days (72 hours)

Maximum duration: 10 days (240 hours)

Colours: Red, yellow, black, green, muddy/ earth-toned.

Starts: When blood leaves the vagina and exits the labia minora even if it hasn’t exited the labia majora. If you put a tampon and blood comes out, BUT there has been no blood *outside* the vagina, haydh has not started.
  • Any coloured discharge during days of haydh counts as menstruation, until the white discharge of tahaara.
  • Even if you have a ‘dry day’ during your cycle, if still within the 10 day menstruation limit, it still counts as menstruation - you still don’t pray.
  • Minimum time duration of tahaarah is 15 days
  • No maximum duration of tahaarah, even if for many months or years

Understanding/determining a regular cycle

  • Determined by number of days of normal bleeding and duration of purity from previous month
  • Use a calendar/app!
  • Your cycle can change. Keep track of previous month!
  • If you have a roughly regular cycle and then end up bleeding extraneously beyond that, the days past your previous longest cycle are now considered istihaadha. E.g. for three months your cycle has been 4-6 days, in the fourth month, you bleed for 10 days - from day 7 and onwards, those days are now considered istihaadha and not haydh.

Prohibitions

  • No salah.
  • No sajdah shukr or tilaawah.
  • If praying a fardh and then period starts, the salah is invalidated and no need to make up. If praying a sunnah or naafilah, then salah is invalidated and it must be made up later.
  • If bleeding begins at the end of a prayer time and you haven’t prayed it yet, you are not obliged to make up that prayer.
  • No fasting
  • All obligatory fasts (from Ramadan) must be made up
  • If bleeding begins while fasting, the fast is invalidated and it must be made up - this applies to both obligatory or voluntary fasting
  • If you stop bleeding before Fajr, in the night of Ramadan,after 10 days have passed, even if it’s one single minute before Fajr, you must fast that upcoming day.
  • If you stop bleeding during the day of Ramadan, the fast doesn’t count, but you must uphold the conditions of fasting.
  • If you stop bleeding before Fajr, in the night of Ramadan, *before* 10 days have passed - and have enough time to do ghusl and say takbir of Fajr - then you fast that day.
  • If you stop bleeding before Fajr, in the night of Ramadan, *before* 10 days have passed - but do NOT have time to do ghusl - then you must behave like a fasting person, but the fast does not count, and you must make it up.
  • Cannot touch the mus’haf
  • Permissible to touch the mus’haf with a cloth etc. - any covering/ barrier that is not attached to the mus’haf
  • Not permissible to touch the mus’haf with any part of your garment (e.g. portion of sleeve, from your dress). Gloves don’t count.
  • Not allowed to recite Qur’an, not even a single ayah
  • Permissible to recite a verse as part of du’a, as long as the ayah itself contains words indicative of du’a - permissible to recite Surah Fatiha as du’a
  • If a teacher of Qur’an, can spell out each word slowly but cannot recite the ayaat
  • Permissible to do dhikr, salawaat on RasulAllah
  • Tawaaf is not allowed
  • Not allowed to enter the masjid
  • A musalla that is not a masjid, is permissible to enter
  • No sex
  • Navel to knee must be covered in front of spouse
  • Permissible to have sex without doing ghusl first IF the period lasted full 10 days/nights; and if prayer time ended in which she was obligated to pray, but did not (she is sinful for not praying tho).
  • If menstrual cycle changes to become shorter than previous one, even though she does ghusl and prays and fasts etc. she cannot have sex until the duration of previous cycle has been met.

End of haydh
  • White/clear discharge
  • If, within 10 days, after doing ghusl and starting to pray, you bleed again - delay your next ghusl until the end of the Mustahabb time of next salah. E.g. you shower and pray Dhuhr, then find more blood - wait until end of Mustahabb time of Asr, check for white/clear discharge. Then do ghusl and pray. If still bleeding, is considered haydh still (until 10 days have passed).
  • You don’t have to take out braids for menstrual ghusl as long as water reaches roots of hair.

Miscellaneous
  • If in state of janaabah when your period starts, you’re not obligated to do ghusl for it until your period is over
  • Makruh for menstruating woman to do ghusl for deceased person
  • If menstruating and hear verse of prostration, you don’t do sajdah tilaawah
  • Mustahabb to do wudhu, sit in your usual prayer place, and do dhikr during that time

Istihaadha
  • Blood outside of menstruation, less than three days or more than ten days
  • Nullifies wudhu
  • If you’re bleeding constantly such that you can’t do wudhu or pray without still bleeding, you are considered ma’dhur.
  • Ma’dhur does one wudhu for each prayer, can pray and read Qur’an etc during the duration of that prayer time
  • Excused amount of blood on a ma’dhur’s clothing is equal to or less than 4 cm
  • Makruh tahrimi for someone to pray in clothing with more blood than that
  • Constant yellow discharge breaks wudhu
  • Condition for continuation of being ma’dhur is that there is blood at least once during every subsequent prayer time
  • No longer ma’dhur if one entire prayer time has passed and you have not bled at all

Exceptional cases:
  • If one has continual dysfunctional uterine bleeding and no longer knows the regular number of days for her menstrual cycle, she takes three days at the estimated time of her cycle and does not pray, fast, etc. Those three days are considered to be absolutely menstruation.
For the next seven days after that, must take a ghusl for each salah. With each prayer, she will also pray a makeup of the previous prayer, in case she was in a state of menstruation without knowing it (during the time of the previous prayer). For the next 20 days after that, a new wudhu for each prayer is required, but she is considered to be in absolute state of purity.
  • If one knows the regular number of days of her cycle, but forgets the TIME of it: she prays for X number of days with fresh wudhu for each prayer. The next 26 days, must do a ghusl for each prayer, plus makeup for previous prayer.


Hanbali Fiqh (Dr Haifaa Younis)

Haydh: The natural, free flowing blood from the womb of a healthy female, during a known and regular time.

Prohibitions:
  • Salah
  • Fasting
  • Tawaf
  • Reading Qur’an by moving the lips. Exception: if you are already haafidhah; if you are in the process of becoming haafidhah; if you are a teacher.
  • Touching the mus’haf without a barrier. WITH a barrier (gloves etc) is permissible
  • Staying in the masjid. Newer fatawah: Permissible if you can guarantee that you are not going to soil the masjid itself with your blood.
  • Divorce during menstruation is not valid and does not count

Haydh obligates:
  • Bulugh (puberty) - first menstrual cycles mean you are now legally Shar’an an adult
  • Ghusl at the end of menstruation
  • Divorce becomes permissible as soon as haydh ends, even before ghusl takes place
  • Making up missed obligatory fasts after period is over
  • Marks the the beginning of ‘iddah
Minimum age: 9 years
  • If a girl bleeds before age 9, it does not count as haydh

Maximum age: Menopause.
  • Generally between the ages of 50 and 60

Colours: Black, red, yellow, brownish/ grey

Minimum duration of haydh: 24 hours (one day and one night)
Maximum duration of haydh: 15 days
Minimum duration of tahaarah: 13 days

A man came to Ali ibn Abi Talib and said, “My wife has three periods in the month. Is that possible?”
Ali said: “Are you sure this is what she has?”
He said: “Yes.”
Ali turned to his companions and asked, “Is this man trustworthy?” They said, “Yes.”
Ali said: “Yes, she can have three periods in the month.”
(Narrated by Bukhari)

Potentially, could have a one or two day period that recurs every 13 days.

Is it over?
  • Blood has ended, with or without white discharge - complete dryness OR white discharge
  • 3 opinions about what ‘white discharge’ means: 1) the pad/tampon comes out white/clean when you swab/ wipe; 2) actual white discharge; 3) bleeding has ended.

Rulings
  • Cycle can change with age/ factors such as travel, birth control etc
  • The first time your cycle changes, go by your normal cycle - the extra days are istihaadha.
  • If the change becomes consistent for three months, this now establishes a new regular pattern, and the extra days DO count as menstruation.
  • If period changes to become shorter, then it is considered to end when the bleeding ends/ usual signs of end of period.
  • “Dry days” between the usual days of period/within 15 days: 2 opinions.
1) All of it is considered your period (minority opinion within Hanaabila)
2) Take ghusl when the bleeding stops, pray etc. then stop when bleeding begins again. Add the bleeding days together, any days of bleeding that exceed 15 days is now considered istihaadha.
  • For first time period: First 24 hours are considered her period, until 3 months have passed and a regular cycle has been established.
  • Birth control and other medical to delay or decrease periods etc. are all considered permissible as long as not harmful for you
  • Regarding regular discharge post-menses: older fataawah said it breaks wudhu; newer fataawah say no, does not invalidate wudhu.
  • Intimacy allowed as long as there is a covering/barrier between the two spouses/ navel to knee should be covered.
  • If in tawaaf and you have vaginal discharge, it is recommended to do leave and do wudhu and come back; but permissible to simply continue the tawaaf.
  • If period begins before Tawaaf al-Ifaadha - wait until the day you have to leave, then perform it.
  • If period begins within a salah/ salah time, you do not have to make up the prayer.


Istihaadha
  • Any non-menstrual and non-post-partum vaginal bleeding
  • Continuous blood flow
  • Often differentiated from menstrual blood by being fresher/ brighter red; menstrual blood is usually dark, thick, has a stronger smell, often clots.
  • Bleeding during pregnancy is NOT period

Miscarriage:
  • Any blood post-miscarriage (if the fetus had any evidence of ‘human creation’) is considered nifaas.
  • Very early miscarriage, only clotting - not nifaas. Considered istihaadha.


Maliki Fiqh (Mona Elzankaly)

Haydh: All blood, yellow or watery pus/discharge, or murky brown discharge that exits on its own from the vagina of a woman who could normally become pregnant.
  • It must come from the vagina - not anus or urethra
  • It has to exit on its own - e.g. not due to pap smear
  • Bleeding before age 9 or after age 70 is not considered menstruation
  • Between ages 9 and 13, and between age 50 and 70, women are consulted to see if it’s seen as menstruation
  • Between ages 13 and 50, definitely considered menstruation

Women are divided into 3 categories:
  • Beginner - her cycle has just begun, first time
  • Experienced - has had at least one cycle
  • Pregnant. Even if a pregnant woman bleeds, one day of blood is seen as a day of menstruation.
Minimum duration of period: One drop of blood - even one drop in the day, the entire day is considered menstruation.

Maximum duration:
  • Beginner: 15 days
  • Experienced: Depends on her previous longest cycle she’s ever had, plus 3 more days. Absolute maximum is 15 days. E.g. Regular cycle is 5 days. Maximum one can go to for current cycle is 8 days (5+3).
  • Pregnant: Within first two months, same as an experienced woman. After third month to sixth month, up to twenty days. After sixth month, up to thirty days.

One day = from Maghrib to Maghrib.

No maximum days of tahaarah; 15 days minimum between cycles.

If one has a cycle where you bleed for X number of days, then dry for X number of days - you do ghusl, pray and fast on the dry days; then you stop when bleeding begins again. Add up all the days of bleeding to get the total number of days for your cycle - they cannot exceed 15 days. Once it exceeds 15 days, any blood afterwards is istihaadha. For a new cycle to begin, there must be 15 consecutive days of tahaarah.

E.g. A’s cycle is 5 days. Then it stops for 3 days. Then it she bleeds again for another 5 days.
She must do ghusl, pray and fast etc. for the 3 dry days. They do NOT count towards the 15 days of tahaarah. For the next 5 days of bleeding, only 3 of those days are considered haydh (due to maximum per that cycle); the next 2 days are istihaadhah. Those 2 days are considered part of the minimum 15 days of tahaarah.
The adding of extra 3 days to previous longest cycle is called “istidh’haar.”

End of period:
  • Thick white or clear discharge
  • Dryness (no bleeding
  • Reaching maximum cycle days
  • Check at the beginning of each prayer time to see if bleeding has ended
  • Disliked to get up before Fajr to check - used to be practise of Bani Isra’eel - but check *at* Fajr time
  • If you check at Dhuhr time and you still have blood, then check at Asr and you are clean - you will pray both Dhuhr and Asr; same for Maghrib and Isha

Istihaadha
  • If there is bleeding for less than half a prayer day (e.g. occasional spotting), it breaks the wudhu and you must make fresh wudhu
  • If there is bleeding for more than half a prayer day (regular bleeding/flow), it does not break wudhu but recommended to renew it
  • If it is constant, then it does not break wudhu and you don’t need to renew wudhu

Prohibitions of menstruation:
  • Salah
  • Fasting
  • Tawaaf
  • Touching the mus’haf. Exceptions: She can recite from memory (or a book that has translation or commentary of the Qur’an); if a student of Qur’an or a teacher, may touch the mus’haf with that specific intention in mind.
  • Sajdah Tilaawah and Sajdah Shukr
  • Entering the masjid and even passing through it (unless life or death situation)
  • Talaq - impermissible to do but valid once issued
  • Intercourse - must cover from navel to the knees, cannot touch private parts


Miscellaneous:

  • Discharge from yeast infection does not nullify wudhu

Who will write the love letters to our families?

Brown people in the West (okay, mostly desis) complaining about their families, about brown families, about the cultural drama and the marriage circus acts and the rest of it have become a staple of Brown People in the West narrative - sometimes accompanied by a dose of guilt-assuaging "but they were immigrants who worked so hard for us so here is a token note of appreciation, mostly about food because we're all still too lazy to learn our grandmothers' recipes."

We write angry hot takes about our racism (which is bad), our colourism (also bad), about arranged marriages and cultural expectations (although apparently arranged marriages are lowkey trendy now? I can't keep up tbh).

Who will write the love letters to our families?
The notes that say: I love my father's sarcasm and his tales of how he was of the first generations of Brown Kids Growing Up in the West; or:
My grandmother's blunt racist comments about our own people (and others) are horrifying but also contain an entire history lesson on Partition, Apartheid, and growing up Muslim in a non-Muslim land that was not in the West; or:
My mother's lingering FOB habits are still mildly annoying and occasionally cringe-worthy, but now I feel fiercely protective of the way she pronounces certain words and only I can laugh at her, but I never want her to stop being the way she is.

Who will write the love letters to our families?
The notes that say: Tribalism is wrong, but I understand why people went to war over the blood they share between one another's veins.
The blood that flows between us is hot with our family pride; it is the blood that we have spilled between ourselves over inheritances and bitter marriages, but every drop is cherished.
Any outsider who dares prick one of us with shame or humiliation will die a thousand deaths from a war raged upon them by every one of us who shares blood and bonds of kinship.

Who will write the love letters to our families?
The notes that say: When my cousin gives birth, her parents will fly from another country to this one; her mother will try to make her the same foods that she once consumed during her confinement, even though my cousin will insist on going for walks with the baby and sneaking some fast food.
When my cousin gives birth, her child will be precious, like mine is: we, this new generation, are reluctant to birth the four, five, six, seven children that our mothers and our grandmothers produced, and so our offspring are ever more carefully guarded.
When my cousin gives birth, her child and my child will the youngest of us, our blood shared in their veins; even now, we all feel the faint tug to cousins and second cousins and third cousins, and their children, despite the distances and the fact that we forget their names or that they even exist.

Who will write the love letters to our families?
The notes that say: I'm sorry you lost your inheritance to that other branch of the family, but thank you for the scandalous stories - of the aunty living under her dead co-wife's identity for over fifty years; of the distant cousins who allegedly committed murder most foul; of the great-aunt and great-uncle whose pot habit was just a matter of fact; of the grandmother's sister's husband, who refused to pray behind anyone else because "they know nothing about the religion!" (and who had a disturbing penchant for schoolgirls, because apparently he knew nothing about what religion had to say about that...).

Who will write the love letters to our families?
The notes that say: I bear the scars of the time I was disowned, of the bitterness that never really went away after divorce, of the terse words and angry tears over a decision that no one will ever really forgive - but still, we are family;
Even when we are tense over certain topics, or barbed comments still slip from our tongues, or we forget sometimes to pretend that nothing really happened, and our voices rise, some shrill, some low, some sharp - still, we are family;
These tongues share the same sharpness, these voices carry the same tenors, these noises hold the same pride, these chins share the same stubbornness - these veins hold the same blood, and so: we are family.

We are bound by a love and loyalty that has no justification or explanation; it lays in the marrow of our bones and the flow of our blood.

Who will write the love letters to our families?

Sunday, November 25, 2018

"Homemaking": A Masculine Endeavour

 The term "homemakers" is used exclusively in relation to women as SAHM, but we completely overlook the fact that to "make a home" involves so much more than a woman staying home and taking care of domestic drudgery.


In the context of a two-parent, heterosexual marriage and family unit, the role of husbands and fathers cannot be overstated. #TrueQawwam doesn't just mean paying the bills - it means being present and active *at home* - making the house a home - and playing an integral role within the family unit beyond merely finances.

A man is - or should be - a homemaker. That means that he is involved with his children, that he is aware of their individual needs and stages of life, that he is concious of how necessary paternal presence and positive attention is in the development of both boys and girls. The effects of paternal neglect - even if the father technically is present - are devastating on children.

Unfortunately, so much of "fatherhood" in many of our communities is restricted to finances and discipline, but ignores the emotional contributions that fathers offer.

#TrueQawwam homemakers are those who actively choose to place their children as an emotional priority. That means that, regardless of the mother and what she is or isn't doing, a male homemaker is invested in his kids, spending time with them, and actively engaged with them. Fathers can be, and should be, nurturing.
Too many people equate the word "nurturing" with "being feminine," which couldn't be further from the truth.

RasulAllah (sallAllahu alayhi wa sallam) provides the perfect model for a nurturing, homemaking #TrueQawwam.

He used to take his daughters with him to the Ka'bah; he hugged and kissed children often; he was emotionally present and had genuine concern for them. He cared about Abu Umayr's dead bird, he had Umayyah bint Qays ride on his camel with him *on the way to battle,* and he carried his grandchildren on his shoulders as he led the entire Muslim community in prayer.
He never pushed children away or told them to go their mothers or dismissed them and their concerns. He had time for them, always.

He trained the young boys and men around him to have good manners; to lower their gazes in front of women; to be generous with kindness and affection. He taught the young girls and women around him that they *mattered,* that they had an active role to play in society, that even if they chose to live a simple and "domestic" life, their efforts never went in vain in the Sight of Allah.

The Messenger of Allah (sallAllahu alayhi wa sallam) was truly a "homemaker" in that he made his house a home for Ali ibn Abi Talib, Zaid ibn Harith, and the children of Umm Salamah - his stepchildren. Each and every one of those children grew up loving the person and the home of the Messenger of Allah, for he was the greatest father figure and nurturer that there ever was.

Ibrahim (alayhissalam) is also the perfect example of a nurturing man - so much so that in Jannah, the souls of young children who passed away reside with him.

Being a "homemaker" is neither demeaning nor exclusively a feminine endeavour. Rather, it is what creates the bedrock of a happy, healthy, stable society - one where men and women both play active roles in raising their children (and others' children as well) with love and wisdom.

Monday, October 29, 2018

On Rape/Sexual Assault Tropes in Muslim Communities – An Islamic Response (Part II)

Editorial Note: TRIGGER WARNING – This article contains explicit stories of sexual assault and trauma. This is part two of a two-part series on rape culture and sexual abuse within Muslim communities and will focus on other arguments used to blame victims as well as examining these arguments from the Islamic standpoint. Part one debunks common false statements often given to excuse or ignore sexual abuse and trauma. Also, the terms “victim” and “survivor” are both used in this piece at the discretion of the person who was relating their story of sexual trauma.
Rape culture isn’t limited to a Muslims nor does it manifest in the same ways in Muslim (or religions) and non-Muslim communities. Each culture and society has certain factors unique to them that contribute to an overall toxic and dangerous environment when it comes to sexual violence. Some attitudes, however are common across communities. The end result, is a deeply painful one: A society in which sexual violence continues to take place, often without consequences, due to the stigma and taboo surrounding the matter as well as its normalization.
In Muslim communities there are certain tropes that are perpetuated by many to excuse (or even justify) sexual violence — some in the guise of religiosity and some as solely cultural. We will continue to examine these tropes, read more stories from victims and consider an Islamic response to these beliefs.
“A woman’s honor lies in her virginity.”
No individual’s “honor” or value as a person or as a Muslim lies in their virginity. While chastity is a value that is deeply important in Islam, it applies to men and women. The Quran speaks highly of believers who maintain their chastity, both within and outside of marriage.
The concept of virginity, however, as held by many people, is not one which has an Islamic basis. The physical state of virginity (i.e. of a person who has not had any sexual interactions before) is praiseworthy for both the Muslim man and women, who have withheld from sexual relationships before marriage. However, virginity can also cease to exist due to factors outside of a person’s control, such as rape. Thus, there is no Islamic evidence to state that any individual’s honor is dependent upon their virginity, or that they lose that honor upon ceasing to be virgins.
Rather, the honor of any individual, man or woman lies in their mere existence as human beings, and in particular, as believers. A woman’s ‘izzah is not stripped away simply because someone violated the sanctity of her body; nor does any boy or man who has been raped or sexually attacked lose their honor.
Verily the most honourable of you in the sight of Allah is (the one who is) the most righteous of you. And Allah has full knowledge and is well acquainted (with all things). (Quran 49:13)
Thus, it is very clearly established that honor lies solely in one’s connection to Allah and not upon unjust standards created by human beings.
“Men and boys can’t be raped.”
This myth is a crippling one, yet is incredibly pervasive amongst both non-Muslims as well as Muslims. The truth is that boys and men are also victims of sexual violence; statistics show that males experience rates of sexual violence roughly equal to women.
Men and boys are just as vulnerable to predators. While currently available records show that at least one in sixteen men and boys have been the victims of sexual assault or rape, the sad truth is that male victims often face even greater stigma than female victims do and thus under-report significantly.
The Muslim community is not immune to this; Muslim boys and men are also victims of sexual assault and violence.
It was my first job at the masjid. My responsibility was to teach the kids after school on secular subjects regarding math and reading. The community I’m from is filled with old men with an urge to assualt and sexually molest little kids.
From the time I was in Sunday school learning Quran I have witnessed teachers sexually touch girls while teaching them how to pray, groping their behind while trying to make their back straight going into ruku and even “accidently falling on them.” These type of people are very common in our community, and when community leaders do this it is very disturbing. Leaders who lead prayer and give khutbah are the rapists who got away with their evil acts. A few years ago a man was caught in the basement of our neighborhood trying to rape a little girl. He is now in prison. The evidence was recorded. If it wasn’t, I’m pretty sure he would have gotten away and still continue his rampage destroying the minds of young boys and girls.
Consider this story:
I was 14 when I got my first job at the masjid. The mu’azin, who was a perverted old man, came to me regarding help on his citizenship test. As a employee of the masjid, I felt as if it was my job to help others who are also part of the masjid. So, after teaching the kids with their homework, I would go to his office to help him with his work. The problem with rapists is that they like to use every chance to get to know you and lure you in to their actions.
Every day when I went, I would notice that he would look at me a certain way and have little focus on what I would say. He would stare at me with his eyes lit up with a perverted smile. I didn’t take this seriously, as I was 14 and well capable of defending myself. The night that threw me off was the day I cut off any relation with this man. He asked me to grab the Quran from his bed, but I refused as I was not comfortable going into his bed. As I was trying to leave, he tried to jump on me. Disgusted, I threw him off me and left. Any other move, he would have been knocked out cold with a broken nose. Since it was the masjid, I tried to keep it cool. He then called me and was trying to offer payment. The payment was not in money but a BANANA.
I let go of his actions, thinking that he would change. I was wrong of that . He later got fired for getting caught sexually molesting a child.
If I had spoken up earlier to any member of the committee, that could have been avoided. That other child could have been saved from the trauma of sexual abuse.
What I have learned through my experience is that staying silent because of fear will only create more trouble for the future. Allowing men to get away with these types of actions makes room for more assaults in the future.” (male victim)
“Only men sexually assault women.”
Another misconception is that only men commit violations of a sexual nature, and too often the focus on preventing sexual crimes tends to hone in on on women wearing hijab and avoiding non-Mahram men.
However, women, too, are capable of such vile actions towards male and female victims.Thirty-five percent of male victims of rape or sexual assault reported female perpetrators; many women also experienced sexual violence at the hands of other women.
It was the summer of 2004. I had just finished up my first year of middle school and was looking forward to the seventh grade. During vacation, my mother, sister and I took a trip to Pakistan. I was 12 years old.
Prior to visiting my family overseas, we would all keep in touch via phone calls. I had a set of cousins who I would routinely talk to. The last time we met was in 2000, so I was looking forward to seeing them all again. I was particularly looking forward to seeing my cousin Alia again. I didn’t have an older sister and she was the next best thing.
Alia changed. She was always tense and very policing. The things that we enjoyed were all of a sudden bad or wrong in her eyes. Every other word that came out of her mouth was a criticism of how I carried myself. I laughed too loudly, I didn’t sit properly, my hair was always down and uncovered, my clothes fit too tight. She mocked me because I had not finished the Quran yet and would constantly ask, “Are you even a Muslim?” or “Do you even believe in Allah?”
One day while I was talking to her brother Daniyal, she barked at me to come in the kitchen. She yelled at me before for talking to him, so I was expecting another scolding. She told me that she wanted to be my friend again and was only harsh because I was a growing girl in need of discipline. She said that I needed to be worthy enough to become her friend again.
One night, as we were all getting ready for bed (I shared a room with my sister and mom during our stay), Alia entered and asked my mom if her and I can have a slumber party. I was never allowed to go to slumber parties back home so I got very excited when my mom said yes.
After entering Alia’s room, I rolled my sleeping bag out on the floor next to hers and we started talking about school. I remember telling her how much I missed her and wanted to have fun with her again
“I always enjoyed having slumber parties with my other cousins but they are too young to understand what we as women know. I am noticing that you are becoming a woman and there are things that you need to know now,” Alia told me.
She attempted to give me “the talk.” I was already aware of the basic mechanics of sex thanks to school, which is why I found her rendition rather comical. Everything she said was wrong, and to this day, I don’t know if she was serious or just making stuff up on purpose. She was 21-years-old, after all. Although I was weirded out by her, I didn’t find her actions threatening. During the day, she would continue to bark at me over everything I did.
The conversations that we had at night would always end up with her talking about sex. When she noticed me getting uncomfortable, she would get angry for not taking her lessons seriously and that I would make a terrible wife. I recall her telling me how I always need to wear sexy underwear, use tongue when I kiss, and regularly shave my body hair.
A few days passed, and [one morning] I woke up as her body was pressed up against me. She was spooning me from behind, and her hands were pressing my chest. I heard her moans in my ear. When I swatted her hand away, she got angry at me and claimed that I hated her. I ended up apologizing and let her sleep the way she wanted to. She insisted that I stroke her breasts, and I complied. This is the farthest it ever went.
The only people who know about these incidents are my close friends. I haven’t told anyone in my family as she is regarded as a respectable, religious woman (still unmarried). I can safely assume that her word will be trusted over mine. Occasionally, whenever I interact with her via Skype, she always tries to give me advice on religion and manners. I don’t take any of it seriously. (female victim)
“This is why women are supposed to stay indoors.”
Women are allowed to leave their homes. We are not obligated to remain indoors at all times, contrary to those who use the Prophetic statement that “women’s homes are better for them” as a way of keeping women controlled and restricted.
The Mothers of the Believers — the wives of RasulAllah (sallAllahu ‘alayhi wa sallam) and his female Companions — all lived their lives normally. They were not confined to their homes nor were they were not commanded to cloister themselves. As long as they observed hijab correctly, they not only left their homes but were actively engaged in the public sphere. Many female Companions ran their own businesses, were farmers, sold their wares in the marketplace, attended the masjid regularly and even joined the Messenger of Allah in jihad. He never prohibited the believing women of his time from leaving their homes, and, indeed, he warned others against forbidding women from attending the masjid.
When it comes to sexual assault, location is irrelevant. It can take place at home or in the street; in a masjid or a park; in a school or at a hospital. A victim should never be blamed for the crime committed against them.
I was 17-years-old, and it was my first umrah trip with my family. It was our first day in Madinah, and we had just come back from Dhuhr salah at the Haram. I was standing in the lobby of our hotel waiting for the lift. My mother and grandparents were with me, as well as some other people I didn’t know who were also waiting for the lift. I was laughing and chatting to my family, when suddenly I felt a hand gripping my buttocks, pinching and rubbing. It took about ten seconds for my brain to register what was happening and then to react, I was in such shock. As I turned around, the man was walking away and out of the hotel.
It happened so quickly that my family didn’t even see it. I started crying immediately.
A number of things that stand out to me about this event:
1) There were people standing around me who surely must have seen it, but didn’t say anything, didn’t try to stop the perpetrator or apprehend him.
2) This happened in this holy city of Madinah. The incident took my self confidence and my sense of security for the rest of the trip. It completely tainted my Umrah experience and led to many months of denial, anger and frustration regarding the toxic culture which plagues the Nabi (s.a.w)’s precious city.
3) when I told some people about this event, they simply said that this is Allah’s will, and He is simply testing my Eemaan. I found this deeply hurtful; it implies that Allah intended for me to go through this trauma. This contradicts my view of a loving, kind and merciful creator. What’s more is that statements like that strip the perpetrators of any responsibility or accountability, as it implies that they are not men with superiority complexes and deeply ingrained toxic masculinity that comes as a result of a patriarchal society, but rather pawns in Allah’s plan of trials and testing for the lives of innocent victims. (female victim)
“There’s no such thing as marital rape.”
The term “marital rape” is a heavily contested one, with many people claiming that there is no such thing in Islam. Regardless of what you want to call it, the mere act of physically forcing an unwilling individual, even if they are your spouse, into an unwanted sexual encounter — such that you are causing them physical, emotional and psychological harm — is completely wrong and sinful.
The hadith of “angels cursing” a wife who rejects her husband’s advances does not justify a man forcing himself upon his wife. Rather, it reinforces that fact that even in a circumstance where a woman refuses to engage in intimacy with her husband, without reason (illness, distress and numerous other factors are all considered to be legitimate reason), he cannot use force against her. Instead, he must console himself with the knowledge of the spiritual consequences for her decision. (It must also be noted that a husband who withholds intimacy from his wife, without legitimate reason, is also considered to be blameworthy.)
Scholars have noted that should a wife continue to withhold from intimacy, the recourse for the husband is to go to the appropriate Islamic legal authority and to seek a means of resolving the matter through them.
For more information regarding the Islamic understanding of marital rape, see here. At the end of the day, regardless of whether you are married to an individual or not, it is not permissible to force anyone into a sexual interaction.
“Someone who was raped is the same as someone who committed zina.”
There is a huge difference between someone who engaged in consensual, impermissible sexual intercourse with another willing party (called zina) and someone who was violated against their will.
The Hadd punishment for rape does not apply to the victim; the only person to be punished is the rapist. In some circumstances, such as if the rapist uses a weapon in any capacity, they may also be considered to fall under the crime of “terrorist,” a crime that incurs a far more severe Hadd punishment than merely lashing or stoning. Nor is a victim of rape obliged to produce four witnesses.
The belief that a victim of rape is equivalent to someone who engaged in zina is one borne of sheer ignorance and has devastating consequences for the innocent women and men who have been victimized. As it is, the psychological repercussions of rape are life-changing; to be accused of being complicit and even blameworthy for the violation is torturous. No one should ever accuse a victim of sexual violence of being responsible for what happened to them.
“These things didn’t happen at the time of the Prophet (sallAllahu ‘alayhi wa sallam) and his Companions. These things don’t happen to pious people.”
This is an example of religious naivete. Even in the time of RasulAllah (sallAllahu ‘alayhi wa sallam), people were people. While there was incredible goodness amongst the earliest Muslims, there were also people who did commit sins. This included everything from alcoholism to theft to zina to, yes, rape.
Narrated Wa’il ibn Hujr:
When a woman went out in the time of the Prophet (ï·º) for prayer, a man attacked her and overpowered (raped) her.
She shouted and he went off, and when a man came by, she said: “That (man) did such and such to me.” And when a company of the Emigrants came by, she said: “That man did such and such to me.”
They went and seized the man whom they thought had had intercourse with her and brought him to her.
She said: “Yes, this is he.” Then they brought him to the Messenger of Allah (ï·º).
When he (the Prophet) was about to pass sentence, the man who (actually) had assaulted her stood up and said: “Messenger of Allah, I am the man who did it to her.”
He (the Prophet) said to her: “Leave, for Allah has forgiven you.” But he told the man some good words (Abu Dawud said: meaning the man who was seized), and of the man who had had intercourse with her, he said: “Stone him to death.”
This hadith alone is proof enough that even in the most sacred of cities, at the time of the Messenger of Allah himself, rape and sexual assault were crimes that existed. The difference, of course, is that RasulAllah (sallAllahu ‘alayhi wa sallam) did not hesitate to deal with the matter immediately and appropriately.
Why Does This Happen? What Can We Do?
Sexual crimes are committed because — to put it very simplistically — the criminal has no fear of Allah. They also have no sense of conscience towards the person whom they have reduced to an object. They may have a sense of power over the victim, whether physical or social. Other factors, such as poverty, lack of education, the increasing prevalence of violent pornography, the normalization of hypersexualization and more also contribute to the sense of emboldenment and entitlement that abusers have.
There is, unfortunately, a great deal of ignorance and even wilful denial over the reality of rape and sexual assault — how it is perceived within the Shar’iah, how common it is in our communities, and how we should deal with it. Our role, as individuals and as a community, is to educate ourselves and our families and work to ensure that we neither perpetrate such crimes nor enable others in doing so.
As Muslims, we must be concerned with justice. We must be dedicated to upholding the rights of the vulnerable, eradicating these types of crimes and dealing with the perpetrators severely. We cannot afford to enable or protect these criminals — our Aakhirah is at stake. We must be willing to have uncomfortable conversations and discussions and even to engage in painful confrontations. Sadly, there are far too many abusers among lay people and those in positions of leadership in our communities. Far too many people would prefer to turn a blind eye to the existence of sexual assault and abuse.
Allah has commanded us to enjoin the good and forbid the evil; we are an Ummah sent to uphold His laws, to hold transgressors accountable, and to fight against oppression wherever it may be – whether it is political or social, from outside of our community or from within it.
Let there arise out of you a group of people inviting to all that is good, enjoining the good and forbidding evil. And it is they who are the successful. (Quran 3:104)
You are the best nation produced [as an example] for mankind. You enjoin what is right and forbid what is wrong and believe in Allah. (Quran 3:110)

Halaloween, Haraamoween

Halaloween is what happens when Muslims don't have the backbone to teach their children to have a sense of self confidence in their Islamic identity, and instead try to weakly overcompensate by doing a fake Halloween at the masjid.
There is literally no need to send your kids to "Halaloween" because you feel bad that they're missing out on actual Halloween.
What you SHOULD feel bad about is that you clearly haven't taught them what it means to be a person of principle and to be okay with not participating in *everything* that nonMuslims do.
Don't tell me "oh but Muslim kids never have fun!"
If your kids don't have fun on a regular basis, that's your fault. Why aren't you doing fun things with them? Family fun nights? Random fun outings and activities with friends?
Teach your kids some basic Islamic identity. Educate your kids about the difference between our Eids, & nonMuslim celebrations that are literally based on shirk and kufr.
Teach your kids to have a spine - to be confident in their identity, to be okay with not fitting in always.
You shouldn't be doing "Halaloween" as a reactionary option to Halloween.
You should be engaged with your kids on a regular basis, having conversations with them daily about these topics and themes, and giving them positive experiences related to Islam and being Muslim. Your kids should associate Islam and being Muslim with happy memories - whether it is making Jumu'ah a daily Eid in practise, or the fun of going to the masjid for Maghrib and Isha and meeting good friends, or playing pingpong and foozball at madrasah.
If your kids think they need Halaloween (or worse: if you think they need Halaloween!) bc there's nothing fun for them... that's your fault.
Here's the thing. Loads of us Muslims grew up in the West, not celebrating such things, and we came out totally untraumatized.
Here's another thing: kids are resilient. They're also not stupid. Talk to them at their level, don't patronize or lecture, but explain WHY we do not celebrate Halloween or Christmas or any other unIslamic holiday.
They actually do get it.
It's parents who are insecure.
Halloween is on a school night this year anyway. There's literally no need to send them to Halaloween bc "oh otherwise they'd be out there with everyone else!"
No, they'd only be out there if you as a parent are incapable of your job in keeping them busy at home.
Better yet, teach your kids what the only meaningful part of Halloween is... the 50% off candy sales the next day.
Priorities, yo.
Look, I grew up in Canada, never celebrated a single nonMuslim holiday in my life despite being surrounded by all the trappings. My siblings and I emerged unscathed and untraumatized. We have great memories of growing up Muslim that had nothing to do with Halaloween.
Tl;dr: Don't be an insecure parent who tries to make up for lack of Islamic conversations with your kids by setting up Halaloween. Just wait for Nov 1st candy sales.

Monday, October 22, 2018

Good Muslim Women

Before you talk about the trauma of motherhood, or how your masjid deliberately excludes women, or how you have been preyed upon by marriage bandits or a superstar da'ee...

You must reassure the patriarchy that you are A Good Muslim Woman.

No, of course you're not a feminist. Of course you hphold Muslim male superiority. Of course you don't think that *all* men are bad. Of course they're not to blame.

Before you talk about being a woman, about what you were told womanhood meant, about becoming a woman...

You must reassure the patriarchy that you are A Good Muslim Woman.

No, of course you don't think that men are responsible for the oppression of women. Of course you think that men have it just as bad, if not worse. Of course you know how privileged women are in Islam.

Before you endure the catcalls you endure every time you walk out of the house, before you talk about the time you were raped, before you talk about being sexually assaulted in Hajj or Umrah, before you mention the abuse of women...

You must reassure the patriarchy that you are A Good Muslim Woman.

No, of course you don't deny the obligation of hijab. Of course you dress appropriately. Of course you were with your mahram. Of course you know that men are abused too.

Before you give a talk or write a book or stand up for a cause or walk into the masjid, before you dare to publicly exist -

You must reassure the patriarchy that you are A Good Muslim Woman.